The Irish Centre for European Law

Please login to your existing account using the entry form opposite, or become an ICEL Member today by entering your email address and selecting the Register button.

Membership Benefits

ICEL Members are able to download/purchase papers and publications, as well as make conference bookings at a significantly discounted rate, in addition to other special offers throughout the year.

Member Login

Lost your password?

Not a member yet?
Create a new account now!

ICEL and University of Exeter Workshop

Precedent in the EU - The Linguistic Aspect

Saturday 5th December, Dun Library, No 6 Kildare Street, Dublin 2

Free workshop, tickets reserved for ICEL members

 

Speakers include:
  • Karen McAuliffe, University of Exeter
  • Lawrence Solan, Centre for Law, Language, and Cognition, Brooklyn Law School
  • John Cooke, former judge at the General Court of the EU
  • Elina Paunio, Court of Justice of the EU
  • Mattias Derlén, Umeå University
  • John Lindholm, Umeå University
  • Gunnar Beck, SOAS, University of London
  • Urska Sadl, iCourts, University of Copenhagen
  • Alex Trklja, University of Exeter

To download a programme, click here.

Outline of workshop

The development of a de facto precedent in EU law has recently been the subject of significant academic debate, centering around questions of what it means for a supreme court to 'make law' and when it is possible to say that its decisions are 'precedents'. While there is no official doctrine of precedent in EU law, the Court of Justice of the European Union (ECJ) does on occasion appear to regard its previous decisions as establishing law that should be applied in later disputes: 'tying down' national courts without establishing a formal hierarchy in the strict sense.

 
There is, however, one important aspect of the development of a de facto precedent in ECJ judgment which has been thus far largely overlooked in the literature: the linguistic aspect. The notion of 'precedent' in any court is the product not only of a conscious jurisprudential strategy, but is also produced by the mechanics of jurisprudential drafting. While those two elements exist in any court, the multilingual nature of the judgments of the ECJ introduces another variable. The judgments of the ECJ are collegiate documents, drafted in French (the working language of that Court) by jurists whose mother tongue is generally not that language.
 
The pleadings, observations, and other documents which inform those judgments undergo many permutations of translation into and out of up to 23 different languages, and the 'authentic' versions of those judgments, as presented to the outside world, are for the most part translations. Questions considering the approximation inherent in translation, how consistently formulaic techniques in the drafting language (which go to the development of precedent) can be carried over to translated versions, and how to ensure the uniform reception of ECJ judgments across 28 member states are all relevant to any consideration of a de facto precedent in EU law.
 
This workshop seeks to address the gap in the literature by bringing together scholars from the fields of language/linguistics and law, as well as practitioners, to consider to what extent language may affect a de facto precedent in ECJ judgments.
 
The workshop forms part of the European Research Council funded project 'Law and Language at the European Court of Justice'.
 
 
Booking
 
This event is free and a number of places have been reserved for members of the ICEL.  To register please click here.  If no tickets are available, please email icel@tcd.ie.
 
 
 

 

 

 

 

News & Events

The ICEL will hold a Consumer Law conference on 7th December.  Click here for details.

The ICEL will hold an EU Employment Law Update on 25th January 2018. Click here for details. 

 

 

ECJ Communiqués »

Commission Communiqués »

Over the past 20 years, the Irish Centre for European Law has provided an important forum for debate and discussion on major developments in the area of EU law. It has been the link between legal practitioners, academics and representatives of the wide range of sectors affected by European Law

Mary McAleese
President of Ireland

Images courtesy of The Irish Times, Trinity College Dublin,
Áras an Uachtaráin and the European Court of Justice
RSS Feed Sources: ECJ & EU Commission